MORGANTOWN, W.V.— Recently, there has been increasing conjecture that West Virginia University, a renowned Big 12 university, may come under NCAA or conference scrutiny. A formal inquiry is not yet underway, but given the increasing punishments imposed on other recent Big 12 colleges, there are a number of historical and current red flags that need consideration.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/73744285/usa_today_24836034.0.jpg)
Shadow of Past Infractions In 2014, the NCAA placed WVU on two years of probation for recruiting infractions involving illegal phone calls and texts en.wikipedia.org +9 reddit.com +9 nypost.com +9 espn.com. Although that incident may seem long away, the NCAA’s “successor liability” policy can have a significant impact, and when a program comes into the public eye, old wounds can swiftly reopen.
Background of Big 12 Cases
There have been a number of sanction announcements for the Big 12, which includes Texas Tech, Virginia Tech, Maryland, and other schools. Before leaving for the Big Ten, Maryland was the subject of multiple campus investigations. In 2021, Texas Tech received widespread censure following coach Chris Beard’s on-field tirade during a conference game against WVU. The conference has demonstrated that it is prepared to intervene, even in cases of misconduct that do not involve NCAA-level infractions.
Things That Could Draw Mountaineer Criticism
Regulations for Transfers and NIL Activity
Under new head coach Darian DeVries, West Virginia has had a high roster turnover rate. The NCAA is still keeping an eye on NIL payments associated with recruitment and transfer portal usage. Although WVU hasn’t made news yet, DeVries’s departure after just one season may lead to investigations into whether recruiting lures were used.
Aggression on the Field and Spectator Incidents
Although Big 12 discipline was comparatively moderate, a WVU football player attacked a spectator during a court-storming incident in 2023. A number of these violations along with a poor institutional response could result in punishment at the conference level.
The High-Profile Coaching Movement
With a shocking upset at the end of the 2024–25 basketball season, WVU missed out on the NCAA tournament with a record of 19–13 and 6 Quad-1 victories. West Virginia’s governor and attorney general threatened an NCAA investigation due to allegations of corruption in the selection process, sparking a state-level uproar. The increased scrutiny may result in offshoot searches into compliance policies, even though this refers to bracket decisions rather than compliance.
Accountability of Institutions
The athletic department at West Virginia seems tense. Governor Patrick Morrisey ordered the attorney general to look into NFL bracket selection, saying the consequence for selection “reeks of corruption.” The mere prospect of judicial scrutiny may increase NCAA interest in program culture—and compliance—even if such state-led initiatives are not directly under its purview.
What Would Actual Sanctions Require?
identification of illegal recruiting inducements, whether via NIL or the transfer portal.
repeated incidents of player misbehavior or unresolved sideline misconduct.
Absence of institutional control in issues like academic integrity, boosters, and eligibility that are governed by the NCAA.
The Last Shot
There isn’t currently a public NCAA or Big 12 investigation of West Virginia’s compliance. However, WVU follows the pattern of programs that might find itself under examination given its probationary history, growing public monitoring, and a department that is in the political spotlight. The lesson? Even well-established programs might abruptly shift their focus, with state-level pressure and prior mistakes serving as the impetus for official investigations.
The upcoming months should be closely monitored by Mountaineer Nation because aggressive discipline, strict institutional monitoring, and transparency in compliance could be the difference between avoiding trouble in the courts or ending up in the penalty box.