“He’s Not THAT Good…” — Tua Tagovailoa’s Viral Practice Clip Has Fans FIGHTING in the Comments
In the social media age, a single clip—especially one involving a polarizing NFL quarterback—can ignite a firestorm of debate. That’s exactly what happened when a recent practice video of Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa went viral with the caption: “He’s Not THAT Good…”
The clip, which appears to show Tua missing a receiver or making an underwhelming throw during Dolphins training camp, quickly circulated on platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok. While some fans laughed off the moment as just a “bad rep,” others took it as proof that Tua still hasn’t lived up to the hype that surrounded him coming out of Alabama.
And just like that, the internet was divided—again.
The Tua Divide
Few quarterbacks in recent memory have been more polarizing than Tua Tagovailoa. Supporters point to his impressive stats from last season, including leading the NFL in passer rating at various points and demonstrating elite accuracy when healthy. His chemistry with wide receivers Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle is undeniable, and the Dolphins offense has looked explosive when he’s at the helm.
However, critics continue to question his ceiling. They argue that Tua lacks elite arm strength, struggles under pressure, and has been too reliant on short passes and timing routes. Concerns about his long-term durability, especially following multiple concussions, have also remained part of the conversation.
The Viral Effect
The practice clip didn’t do Tua any favors in the public perception battle. Though it’s common knowledge that training camp is where mistakes are supposed to happen—where players are trying new things, building chemistry, and working through errors—the internet often lacks that nuance. A poorly timed throw becomes “evidence” for critics. A dropped pass can fuel hot takes. And when the clip is paired with a provocative caption like “He’s Not THAT Good,” it’s a recipe for chaos in the comments.
Indeed, fans began clashing immediately. Tua loyalists pointed out that every quarterback, including the likes of Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen, makes mistakes in practice. Others responded with side-by-side videos of clean throws and deep bombs to highlight his skill set. Meanwhile, skeptics doubled down, claiming the video proves what they’ve always believed: that Tua is more of a system QB than a franchise savior.
The Bigger Picture
The viral clip may not be a true indicator of Tua’s talent, but it highlights a larger trend in the modern NFL—where perception is shaped not just by performance, but by what goes viral. A 10-second video can do more damage to a reputation than a full season of solid play if the narrative catches on.
For Tua, the best response won’t come in the form of another training camp video. It’ll come during the regular season, when he’ll have the chance to silence critics the only way that matters—by winning games.
Until then, the internet debate rages on.